Yesterday, The House of Representatives voted 405-1 for a resolution in support of the Iranian dissidents and condemning the ruling government. And the one man who opposed it was...Rep. Ron Paul
Speaking from the Floor before the vote, the Congressman said,
I rise in reluctant opposition to H Res 560, which condemns the Iranian government for its recent actions during the unrest in that country. While I never condone violence, much less the violence that governments are only too willing to mete out to their own citizens, I am always very cautious about "condemning" the actions of governments overseas. As an elected member of the United States House of Representatives, I have always questioned our constitutional authority to sit in judgment of the actions of foreign governments of which we are not representatives. I have always hesitated when my colleagues rush to pronounce final judgment on events thousands of miles away about which we know very little. And we know very little beyond limited press reports about what is happening in Iran.
Of course I do not support attempts by foreign governments to suppress the democratic aspirations of their people, but when is the last time we condemned Saudi Arabia or Egypt or the many other countries where unlike in Iran there is no opportunity to exercise any substantial vote on political leadership? It seems our criticism is selective and applied when there are political points to be made. I have admired President Obama's cautious approach to the situation in Iran and I would have preferred that we in the House had acted similarly.
I adhere to the foreign policy of our Founders, who advised that we not interfere in the internal affairs of countries overseas. I believe that is the best policy for the United States, for our national security and for our prosperity. I urge my colleagues to reject this and all similar meddling resolutions.
Other prominent conservatives are supporting Preeident Obama's tone-perfect position on Iran.
Sen. Richard Lugar (R-IN), the ranking Republican on the Foreign Relations Committee, Republican senators, including Sens. Mel Martinez (R-FL), Bob Corker (R-TN) and John Thune (R-SD). Ex- Sec of State Kissinger said,
Well, you know, I was a McCain supporter and — but I think the president has handled this well. Anything that the United States says that puts us totally behind one of the contenders, behind Mousavi, would be a handicap for that person. And I think it’s the proper position to take that the people of Iran have to make that decision.
Of course, we have to state our fundamental convictions of freedom of speech, free elections, and I don’t see how President Obama could say less than he has, and even that is considered intolerable meddling. He has, after all, carefully stayed away from saying things that seem to support one side or the other. And I think it was the right thing to do because public support for the opposition would only be used by Ahmadinejad ...
Reading a piece by Lila Ghobady, I gain an Iranian perspective. In part, she writes,
.....No change is possible while Iran is controlled by autocratic, fundamentalist religious despots who determine the laws of the land. There has been no real election. Candidates are all hand-picked and cleared by a central religious committee. It is a farcical imitation of the free nomination/ election process that we have pictured in the free world. There is no possibility that a secular, pluralistic, freedom-loving democratic person who loves his or her country can become a candidate to run for president (or any other office) in Iran.
.....The people of Iran are fed up with poverty, injustice, corruption and international embarrassment with the knuckle-dragging, anti-Semitic, war-mongering cretin who is President Ahamdinejad. They chose to support a bad choice – Mousavi – rather than something worse choice, Ahmadinejad. When an election is really a selection, choice is an illusion.
.....Let us not forget that Mousavi was Prime Minister of Iran in the 1980s, when more than ten thousand political prisoners were executed after three-minute sham trials. He has been a part of the Iranian dictatorship system for the past 30 years. If he had not been, he would not be allowed to be a candidate in the first place.
Mir Hossein Moussavi may be a changed man. Some women in Iran looked to Moussavi to carry their banner, perhaps because they were inspired by his wife, Zahra Rahnavard, a much-admired academic who told CNN's Amanpour that Iran's 34 million women want civil laws and family laws revised. Ahmadinejad's fundamentalism has pushed Iranian women to the edge.
I have no objection to the last addition to your hit list, Petro. But when the Iranians are shouting "death to the dictator", I think they mean Khamenei.
You are correct Vigil. The Iranian people, especially the younger crowd, are tired of being repressed by the religious zealots that have have ruled for far too long.
It is always disturbing to see ultra-conservative repression unleashed. The senseless murder of the young and idealistic Neda Agha-Soltan was a horrible crime against all humanity. Ultra-conservative paranoia and excesses, whether in Iran or here, always seem to manifest themselves in vicious attacks on others, often innocent others. May young Neda's idealism and spirit live on forever and lead to the eventual destruction of the intolerant Iranian regime!
The notion that a radical is one who hates his country is naive and usually idiotic. He is, more likely, one who loves his country more than the rest of us, and is thus more disturbed than the rest of us when he sees it debauched. He is not a bad citizen turning to crime; he is a good citizen driven to despair.
Reverend G R Gleig, survived the First Anglo-Afghan War to write in 1843:
...a war begun for no wise purpose, carried on with a strange mixture of rashness and timidity, brought to a close after suffering and disaster, without much glory attached either to the government which directed, or the great body of troops which waged it. Not one benefit, political or military, has Britain acquired with this war. Our eventual evacuation of the country resembled the retreat of an army defeated.
Open Thread February 22 2025
-
Yesterday, The Conversation newsletter included an article titled “Making
sex deadly for insects could control pests that carry disease and harm
crops.” I ...
Sat, Feb 22
-
2018—After jabbing him in the legs and groin for 2.5 hours, Alabama prison
officials wheel cancer patient Doyle Hamm out of the death chamber alive.
2004—A...
Crowns & Chains
-
Article I, Section 9, Clause 8:
No Title of Nobility shall be granted by the United States: And no Person
holding any Office of Profit or Trust under the...
Did Putin Win Our Election?
-
There is a conspiracy theory that I want everyone to consider. Now the only
evidence I have for my theory is the news itself and so don't automatically
b...
President Carter Tried to Warn Us
-
Entering the Twenty-First Century--The Global 2000 Report To The President
The Global 2000 Report to the President was a report commissioned during
t...
Bernie Has It Right...
-
*When you run after your thoughts, you are like a dog chasing a stick:
every time a stick is thrown, you run after it. Instead, be like a lion
who, r...
Gone but not Forgotten
-
Been years since this site has been public. I only reactivated it because
over the years I've lost several good friends who visited here and I at
their ...
More fictional presidents
-
An article in The New York Times Magazine reminds me of my typology of
stories involving fictional US presidents. Fictional presidents appear in
three kind...
Otwarcie Salonu Lexusa w Olsztynie
-
„Witamy w Lexus Olsztyn” to hasÅ‚o przewodnie podczas otwarcia salonu Lexusa
w Olsztynie . To był emocjonujący wieczór, pełen atrakcji. Na scenie
wystąpił m...
Are Red States Fudging Their Covid-19 Data?
-
Print Accusations some states have manipulated Covid-19 data to make
themselves look better and support political objectives date to the
earliest days of...
What to Look for in a Gun Safe
-
People buy gun safes and lockers for many different reasons. However, the
most common and common-sense intended purpose is for the protection of
young lo...
The Sound Of Not Silence
-
Towards the end of last week the Blue Angels were in town for weekend
shows. There were many flyovers. Did a number of videos just because but
there was so...
Who's Packing Your Parachute?
-
I had to share this with you because it is so true and
inspirational!
These are great thoughts for all of us!! Charles Plumb was a US Navy jet
...
Lost in Translation
-
The Academy Awards have come and gone and the ratings continue to be in
free fall. They lost approximately 6 million viewers from last year and put
up an...
Dakota 38... The Truth... The Killing (Video)
-
*As we approach December 26th 2016, It is time that we see and learn the
truth of December 26th 1862. As in a few days from now, many Native
Americans and ...
Resting In Peace
-
It falls upon me to make the following sad announcement: Anne ("Lil'
Bill") Warburton has passed on peacefully, one week short of her 92nd
birthday. She w...
Testing testing 123
-
Wow, what a mess… spam all over the place!! Must do MASSIVE house cleaning,
then figure out how to work WordPress again… everything’s different now. I
gues...
In Case You Missed It...
-
The blog has moved to a slightly different address:
youwillanyway2.blogspot.com. Come on over. ....but hey, do what you
want....you will anyway.stenium_url...
Who wants peace on earth?
-
I wanted to see the North Korean government get whacked so I watched Team
America (2004) last week, too violent and not for kids, but there was a
funny thi...
NC vs. TN: A Race to the Bottom
-
Last month I wrote about how Tennessee welcomes you unless you're gay,
poor, or have special needs. I related how I was too embarrassed to tell
people wher...
With "Friends" Like Yemen's, No Enemies Needed
-
In early January 2011, former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton
landed in Sana'a to manage the autocratic habits of a useful ally in the
war agains...
This blog is not currently active.
-
It was used for many years but I now blog at leftwingnutjob.net. Check it
out. But this one is only a warehouse for old posts.
Sorry about that!
-
To anyone who is still trying to visit this site: I'm so sorry that it has
been allowed to go fallow. I'm FURIOUS with the asshats at Echo for having
lost ...
on getting tough with God
-
Have ya ever wondered where God is when you Really need Him?
Ever get Really mad and say - Where is God in this time of My Great Need?
If you have ever fou...
Dodgers Now blog redesigned, has new address
-
The L.A. Times Dodgers Now blog has been redesigned, and with our new duds
we're rolling out a new URL. So if you've been a loyal follower of Steve
Dilbeck...
Great Depression II
-
From a N.Y. Times commenter:
I'm... an independent who could not bring myself to vote for any of these
republican candidates. In fact, I believe they would...
"Failure" of the Super Committee??
-
This concept has been kicked around for a few days, but TPM boils it down
nicely -- if Congress were to do nothing, then deficits would go WAY down.
Now, ...
In case anyone is still visiting this blog ...
-
I stopped updating this blog last year, and I am no longer writing for Mad
Mike's. You can now find my volunteer prose poetry and musings at RoundTree7,
wh...
WE ARE FAR TOO TOP-HEAVY!
-
*"Corporations are NOT people! Money is NOT free speech!" - TomCat,
www.politics.plus.org -*
*"Advertising is legalized lying." - H.G. Wells -*
Big bu...
Michael Moore: America Is Not Broke
-
Speech delivered at Wisconsin Capitol in Madison, March 5, 2011America is
not broke.Contrary to what those in power would like you to believe so that
you'l...
COUSIN MICKEY AND THE HEN HOUSE
-
*Cousin Mickey contacted me on Face Book the other day and suddenly a host
of childhood memories flooded in. Mickey lived in Estill Springs, my
Mom's h...
-
A New Day
*To Mac's cherished readers and fellow bloggers:*
While living life to it's fullest, Mac always had an optimistic view for
tomorrow. "Tomorro...
Kit, Unwired
-
My life is in transition, and my daughter Casie and I are in the process of
moving. We've looked at a few places, from rooms to rent to apartments and
may...
Justifiable Police Brutality
-
If I reacted to being stopped and cited for jay-walking in this manner, and
resisted arrest, I would expect to get a pop in the nose. Or something.<i...
Matthew Alexander
-
Matthew Alexander (a pseudonym) is a former senior military interrogator
and author of How to Break a Terrorist: The U.S. Interrogators Who Used
Brains, No...
Racism in China
-
Lou Jing sings Shanghai opera and speaks fluent Mandarin, but when she
competed to be China's next reality TV pop star, it was not her voice that
was crit...
The Magic Roundabout
-
Back in the day there was a hugely popular children’s TV show in Blighty
called The Magic Roundabout. One of its many much loved characters was a
stoned ra...
My once-great country's only hope was to remove Bush from office before his term expired to permit the early repair of the devastation he created. Now the USA is on life support.
Thanks for linking this, P.K.!
ReplyDeleteExpect a bloodletting. A river a green will be swallowed in a sea of red.
ReplyDeleteThis is one time when Petro might actually be right.
ReplyDeletePeeKay? I thought he was dead.
I'll guess we will see tomorrow.
ReplyDeleteI knew Peekay was alive, I saw him two weeks ago hanging out at a Krispy Kreme with Elvis and Jim Morrison.
And I'll be honest Jim is fatter than Elvis.
Yesterday, The House of Representatives voted 405-1 for a resolution in support of the Iranian dissidents and condemning the ruling government. And the one man who opposed it was...Rep. Ron Paul
ReplyDeleteSpeaking from the Floor before the vote, the Congressman said,
I rise in reluctant opposition to H Res 560, which condemns the Iranian government for its recent actions during the unrest in that country. While I never condone violence, much less the violence that governments are only too willing to mete out to their own citizens, I am always very cautious about "condemning" the actions of governments overseas. As an elected member of the United States House of Representatives, I have always questioned our constitutional authority to sit in judgment of the actions of foreign governments of which we are not representatives. I have always hesitated when my colleagues rush to pronounce final judgment on events thousands of miles away about which we know very little. And we know very little beyond limited press reports about what is happening in Iran.
Of course I do not support attempts by foreign governments to suppress the democratic aspirations of their people, but when is the last time we condemned Saudi Arabia or Egypt or the many other countries where unlike in Iran there is no opportunity to exercise any substantial vote on political leadership? It seems our criticism is selective and applied when there are political points to be made. I have admired President Obama's cautious approach to the situation in Iran and I would have preferred that we in the House had acted similarly.
I adhere to the foreign policy of our Founders, who advised that we not interfere in the internal affairs of countries overseas. I believe that is the best policy for the United States, for our national security and for our prosperity. I urge my colleagues to reject this and all similar meddling resolutions.
Other prominent conservatives are supporting Preeident Obama's tone-perfect position on Iran.
ReplyDeleteSen. Richard Lugar (R-IN), the ranking Republican on the Foreign Relations Committee, Republican senators, including Sens. Mel Martinez (R-FL), Bob Corker (R-TN) and John Thune (R-SD). Ex- Sec of State Kissinger said,
Well, you know, I was a McCain supporter and — but I think the president has handled this well. Anything that the United States says that puts us totally behind one of the contenders, behind Mousavi, would be a handicap for that person. And I think it’s the proper position to take that the people of Iran have to make that decision.
Of course, we have to state our fundamental convictions of freedom of speech, free elections, and I don’t see how President Obama could say less than he has, and even that is considered intolerable meddling. He has, after all, carefully stayed away from saying things that seem to support one side or the other. And I think it was the right thing to do because public support for the opposition would only be used by Ahmadinejad ...
I am refraining from joing Twitter for fear my email will be inundated. Is that fear justified?
ReplyDeleteReading a piece by Lila Ghobady, I gain an Iranian perspective. In part, she writes,
ReplyDelete.....No change is possible while Iran is controlled by autocratic, fundamentalist religious despots who determine the laws of the land. There has been no real election. Candidates are all hand-picked and cleared by a central religious committee. It is a farcical imitation of the free nomination/ election process that we have pictured in the free world. There is no possibility that a secular, pluralistic, freedom-loving democratic person who loves his or her country can become a candidate to run for president (or any other office) in Iran.
.....The people of Iran are fed up with poverty, injustice, corruption and international embarrassment with the knuckle-dragging, anti-Semitic, war-mongering cretin who is President Ahamdinejad. They chose to support a bad choice – Mousavi – rather than something worse choice, Ahmadinejad. When an election is really a selection, choice is an illusion.
.....Let us not forget that Mousavi was Prime Minister of Iran in the 1980s, when more than ten thousand political prisoners were executed after three-minute sham trials. He has been a part of the Iranian dictatorship system for the past 30 years. If he had not been, he would not be allowed to be a candidate in the first place.
Mir Hossein Moussavi may be a changed man. Some women in Iran looked to Moussavi to carry their banner, perhaps because they were inspired by his wife, Zahra Rahnavard, a much-admired academic who told CNN's Amanpour that Iran's 34 million women want civil laws and family laws revised. Ahmadinejad's fundamentalism has pushed Iranian women to the edge.
ReplyDeleteI have no objection to the last addition to your hit list, Petro. But when the Iranians are shouting "death to the dictator", I think they mean Khamenei.
ReplyDeleteThe reliable think tank, Chatham House, establishes this election as a sham. Ahmadinejad's rural popularity is a myth.
ReplyDeleteYou are correct Vigil. The Iranian people, especially the younger crowd, are tired of being repressed by the religious zealots that have have ruled for far too long.
ReplyDeleteMir Hossein Mousavi has published on his Web site "Kalemeh" (The Word) a letter addressing the people.
ReplyDeleteIt is always disturbing to see ultra-conservative repression unleashed. The senseless murder of the young and idealistic Neda Agha-Soltan was a horrible crime against all humanity. Ultra-conservative paranoia and excesses, whether in Iran or here, always seem to manifest themselves in vicious attacks on others, often innocent others. May young Neda's idealism and spirit live on forever and lead to the eventual destruction of the intolerant Iranian regime!
ReplyDelete